What the public doesn’t hear — a project

Got 10 minutes? This could matter to you if you care about crime and the media and policing in Winnipeg.

While Menno criticizes the Winnipeg police for cancelling media briefings with reporters [and reporters for letting them do it unchecked] — and implies that there’s some political motivation behind it, I thought I’d weigh in on the experience with dealing with the Public Information Unit as a journalist.

First thing’s first: there’s limited staffing and limited resources in the unit. There are two active PIO/ police officers with Glocks and one information assistant who carries no weapon but her quick wit.

Each of these people are extremely pleasant to deal with and are typically speedy about responses to inquiries from reporters.

One of the officers is fairly new to the gig and deserves time to find her place in the scheme.

The most common mistake journalists make is assuming that the PIO knows about everything that the service is up to.

Point blank: they don’t.

My understanding is that the heads of the WPS’s individual units brief the PIO about [what they feel are] significant events and discussion happens about what the public is told, if anything.

The items chosen are vetted by the executive, and run past the legal department to identify potential issues with the release of information.

My sources tell me that the latter is particularly hard-nosed when it comes to what gets out in terms of official statements from the WPS.

Bearing this in mind, occasions do arise fairly often where a reporter finds out about an event that was never publicly disclosed by the PIO.

A request is sent for information, and depending on what it is, it appears an internal negotiation takes place about what to say by way of official response to the request.

This, in my experience, is where the breakdown between the media and the PIO hits a rut.

But I’ve come to learn that while it may be easy to say the PIO is being unreasonable or stingy with info, there’s reasons behind the madness.

Recent example: on July 15, a man is arrested for aggravated sexual assault in the downtown area near Central Park.  It’s a rare charge that denotes not only a horrible crime, but a horrible, life-altering incident of violence. In my mind, it’s second only to murders, simply because the victim is typically scarred for life by what happened.

Digging a little deeper, I find that the suspect in the case is what might generously be called a career criminal.

So, naturally curious, I send a request to the PIO for information, as the public was never notified that it happened.

I initially thought it related to a serious sexual assault they talked about in June, but as it turn out, was not.

Some information is nearly immediately sent my way, but it’s so scant:

“You have most of the details….. Winnipeg Police arrested 29 year old *** on July 13th for a sexual assault that occurred between June 23 – 24th to a 27 year old female in the 300 block of Quappelle.

*** was charged with aggravated sexual assault.

It’s so scant that it begs for a follow-up reply asking a few more questions, including why the public was never notified.

I get one later saying that the hope was to provide more info on Saturday … two days later.

Again, I asked why they didn’t release on such a serious crime, and wasn’t given a response.

On Sunday, I inquire again if anything more was coming.

“It’s still under investigation,” I’m told.

It seems weird to me. One of the most serious charges in the book laid against someone, and it’s still under investigation.

But at that point, when you hear those words ‘still under investigation,’ I’ve learned there’s no further response forthcoming.

Your best bet is to hit the street and start the digging process to find out what you want to know.

In this case, thank God for the court system is all I can say.

As there’s a publication ban on the case [the first thing the Crown asked for when it came before a judge], I can’t say much, but I can say this case could turn out to be a real bag of hurt for the cops, who are, my sources tell me, now suddenly very much interested in continuing the investigation.

But that’s beside the point, and I’ll fill in the blanks of that story when I can.

However,  what seemed like an unreasonable delay and response from the PIO in terms of my request turned out to be totally justifiable in terms of their having to act responsibly.

But if my estimation of how the public information system works is correct [and I believe it is], the unit commanders at the WPS have some explaining to do.

This week, I undertook a little project, which I will continue from here on in.

I call it the ‘what the public doesn’t hear about’ project.

And here it is. For the last five working days, M-F, I have documented the arrests made by the WPS that resulted in an adult, non-domestic violence-related suspect being locked up at the Remand Centre pending a bail hearing.

I have also documented what the PIO released on that day.

You’ll note some extreme differences in what’s going on ‘out there’, and what the public’s being told. Not to mention the amount of criminal activity officers are out on the streets cracking down on.

Here goes week one of the project. I’m open to your thoughts.

Monday media briefing held. Topics were: Fraud investigation, fire investigation and MVC involving stolen vehicle.

Of these items,  none requested the public’s assistance in obtaining information. There was the addition of one missing persons report which did ask for help locating the person, nothing unusual.

The fraud involved the discovery of money stolen from a hospital ATM over a period years [did nobody notice missing money from a bank machine for years? really?] The fire happened two days prior and simply said arson officers were investigating the cause. The MVC was more current, happening just about 12 hours prior to releasing info. It involved police property being damaged.

Now, on the adult criminal intake docket [people arrested and locked up] from the weekend – does not include domestic violence-related arrests, youths arrested or people arrested and released on a promise to appear:

  • Male, charged with a home invasion, robbery with a weapon and robbery
  • Male, charged with assault with a weapon, uttering threats
  • Male, charged with 75 gun-offences, including weapons trafficking between December 2009 and July 12
  • Male, charged with assault
  • Male and a co-accused male, each charged with 2x break, enter and theft
  • Male, charged with 8 gun offences and drug possession
  • Male, assault
  • Male, mischief
  • Male, robbery
  • Male, charged with 58 gun offences and drug possession for the purpose of trafficking x3
  • Male, uttering threats
  • Male, assault peace officer, assault with a weapon, careless use of a firearm, breach of a court-ordered weapons prohibition
  • Male, mischief, drug possession
  • Male, theft under $5,000
  • Male, theft under $5,000
  • Female, prostitution-related
  • Male, theft under $5,000

Note: These offences occurred between Friday morning and early Monday. I have omitted charges such as breaches to tally only new substantive offences.

I note that none of the weapons-related arrests appear to be related on paper.

So, over the weekend, that’s 18 unpublicized arrests – four of them involving guns or busts of alleged gun-runners. Admittedly, some on the surface appear minor, but if you’re getting locked up on a theft under $5,000, there’s likely more to it than meets the eye.


Tuesday –

Media briefing held, but nothing specific noted on the agenda other than a discussion of a Stats-Can report on police-reported crime in 2009. Report notes violent crime on the rise by 15 per cent in Winnipeg over 2008 levels. Also note: No person from the executive [chief, dep. chief, inspector or superintendent] appears before the media to discuss what’s been happening.

Of two other items released Tuesday — by emailed news release — one requested the public’s assistance for information [a robbery], suggesting that this was the motivation for bringing it to the media’s attention. The other involved a public warning about a lost Taser cartridge, I think the third time this has happened in recent memory.

Now, on the adult criminal intake docket from Tuesday [people arrested and locked up] – does not include domestic violence-related arrests, youths arrested or people arrested and released on a promise to appear:

  • Male, assault cause bodily harm, theft under $5,000
  • Male, assault cause bodily harm, 2x assault with a weapon
  • Female, public mischief
  • Female, assault peace officer
  • Female, assault with a weapon
  • Male, trespassing
  • Male, robbery with a weapon
  • Female, assault cause bodily harm, aggravated assault, uttering threats, possession of property obtained by crime, fail comply with youth sentence. [incidents occurred July 11, she wasn’t arrested until Monday.]
  • Female, fail conditional sentence order

Note: I have omitted charges such as breaches to tally only new substantive offences.


Wednesday –

Media briefing held, with two items on the agenda. An update to a past homicide file [New arrests in the Ricky Lathlin case from Gilbert Park] and the announcement of a new sex-trade enforcement program targeting child sex-trade workers.

Of these items,  none requested the public’s assistance.

On the adult criminal intake docket from Wednesday [people arrested and locked up] – does not include domestic violence-related arrests, youths arrested or people arrested and released on a promise to appear:

  • Male, possession for purpose of trafficking, possession of property obtained by crime [he was pending on a possession charge already]
  • Male, housebreak enter to commit robbery or assault
  • Male, possession
  • Male, possess prop OBC under $5,000, possession purpose trafficking x4 and possession of weapon for dangerous purpose
  • Male, robbery, fail to attend court
  • Male, conspiracy to commit an indictable offence [co-conspirators not IDd] Offence date was Apr. 10, he was arrested Tuesday.
  • Female, robbery with violence and intent to steal
  • Female, aggravated assault, possess weapon for a dangerous purpose
  • Male, sexual assault [incident was Feb. 4]
  • Female, theft under $5,000
  • Male, uttering threats [but was locked up, indicating there’s more to this than meets the eye on paper]

Note: I have omitted charges such as breaches to tally only new substantive offences.

Later in the day, there was a police-involved shooting on Alexander – PIO called in on OT to address the media at 9:30 p.m.


Thursday –

Briefing Held – on the agenda: Internet luring arrest, update to the police shooting, a sexual assault and an assault with a weapon. The office was closing at 12:30 p.m, media were warned. No reason was given for the altered schedule.

That being said, the PIO was clearly returning calls to media about requests that had been made. I received one at 3:00 p.m. in response to a query made after 12:30 p.m.

On the adult criminal intake docket from Thursday – does not include domestic violence-related arrests, youths arrested or people arrested and released on a promise to appear:

[It appeared to be a slow day on Wednesday!]

  • Female, prostitution-related
  • Female, theft under $5,000
  • Male, break, enter and theft, fail to comply with youth sentence
  • Female, aggravated assault
  • Also, Gary Palmer, the independent GWL broker who bilked clients out of their cash was arrested for allegedly breaching his bail.

Note: I have omitted charges such as breaches [Palmer excepted] to tally only new substantive offences.


Friday –

Media briefing held. On the agenda: an update to the officer-involved shooting – suspect ID’d and picture released. Others: The bizarre arrest of an off-duty RCMP officer who found his way into a stranger’s home while drunken, and a notification about an arrest in connection to the sale of mouthwash or whatever non-potable gunk to drunks in the downtown.

On the adult criminal intake docket from Friday – does not include domestic violence-related arrests, youths arrested or people arrested and released on a promise to appear:

  • Male, Robbery, non-compliance with a conditional sentence
  • Female, prostitution-related, theft under $5,000
  • Male, theft under $5,000 x3
  • Male, theft under $5,000
  • Female, theft under $5,000 [pending on two other theft under charges — likely chronic shoplifter]
  • Male, possession for the purpose of trafficking x2, gun offences x4 and possession of property obtained by crime
  • Male, theft under
  • Male, robbery with a weapon x2, break and enter with intent to commit robbery or violence
  • Male, robbery with a weapon x2, break and enter with intent to commit robbery or violence [co-accused to above]
  • Male, robbery with a weapon, drug possession
  • Male, robbery with a weapon
  • Male, break, enter and theft, fail to comply with youth sentence
  • Male, mischief to religious property and failing curfew [see Sun’s story from today. Guy’s name is Jessie Garret Thompsett].


So, there you have week one of this ongoing project. Again, I ask for your suggestions on how this could be improved, bearing in mind I’m not flush with time to sift through all the paper.

I leave it to you to come to your own conclusions about what this means. Remember, this denotes but a fraction of the results police have demonstrated this week in terms of arrests made, crimes possibly solved.

Assuming, that is, that they have the right suspect.

What I take away from it is that while a number of serious incidents went unreported, I don’t believe the PIO is, at root, the reason for this.

I note that each day of this week, reporters got face time with the police, contrary to Menno’s assertion that cancellations of daily briefings are deliberate.

I also note that anyone wanting a taste of how the police and the media interacted prior to the adoption of the PIO system, head down to your library and look at some of the absolutely great police-related stories from the early 90s by Cory Castagna of the Sun, or Mike McIntyre from the Sun and later, the FP.

It used to be very different.

Kraut King’s example

From Dobbin:

“Even the Global News reporters had to call the police about threats when they were doing their reports.”

I heard this call on the police scanner at work yesterday afternoon. We had a giggle at the competition’s woes, but then realized all the stories about dangerous downtown drinking of late were 100 per cent accurate.

Thanks, Sean Kavanagh of the CBC for getting the ball rolling, leading Thundersky to call us to tell us her story of downtown woe.

I wish my employer would allow video embeds. For now, here’s the Global story.

‘Work to do’ + ‘right direction’

“I think you have to look at what we are doing…We have LiveSafe programs, we have SPIN [?] programs … we have more young people participating in sports to make sure they’re off the streets. Uh, we’re working with the WPS. We’ve just added a police helicopter to, you, know, fight crime. We just added a cadet program…

“And as a matter of fact, we’re no longer uhh, the uhh, how they used to say it – the auto theft capital of Canada. So it just goes to show that some of the programs we’ve implemented are working, but by the same token, we still have a great deal of work to do, but we certainly are moving in the right direction.”

—-Mayor Sam Katz responding to criminologist Rick Linden’s assertion the city needs to do more about crime prevention in the wake of a large rise in violent crime severity reported by the WPS in 2009.

‘Work to do’

“I know it’s not going to be easy. I know we have a lot of work to do” Katz, Jan 2, 2004, Winnipeg Sun.

“We have some hard work to do here at City Hall.” Katz, Mar. 27, 2005, Winnipeg Sun.

“People have to realize that as the mayor, you have a lot of work to do every day.” Katz, Aug. 4, 2006. Sun.

“We still have a lot of work to do, there’s no question about that…”Katz,  Feb 29, 2008. WFP

“You’ve got Higgins, you have the Louise Bridge, you have the Disraeli. We have so much work to do and unfortunately we were never given the opportunity — and they’re all linked together.” Katz, June 24, 2008. WFP

“The bottom line for me as mayor is that we have work to do.” Katz, Mar. 6, 2009. WFP

“We still have much more work to do.” Katz, July 22, 2009

“We have a lot of work to do in organics and recycling, but I think we’re moving in the right direction.” Katz, Feb, 18, 2010.

‘Right direction’

“…our downtown is moving in the right direction.” Katz, June 26. 2004 WFP

“I believe that rapid transit will be yet another positive step in the right direction to further revitalize downtown…” Katz, July 12, 2004 [in a 2003 letter to then-mayor Glen Murray.] WFP

“It’s a step in the right direction.” Katz, Nov. 23 2004. WFP

“… very small half-steps in the right direction” Katz, May 17, 2005 WFP

“If you’re heading in the right direction — keep walking.” Nov. 19, 2005 WFP

“We are still facing a $1-billion infrastructure deficit, but we are moving in the right direction.” Katz [self-authored Winnipeg Sun column] Dec. 24, 2005

“That’s also in the right direction…But at least we know we’re in the right direction,” Katz, Dec. 31, 2005, Winnipeg Sun.

“Today’s groundbreaking of the Strand is another step in the right direction.” Katz, April 11, 2006 WFP

“We’re moving in the right direction. We need to do more.” June 6, 2006 Winnipeg Sun

“Will it stop street racing in our city? Probably not entirely. But it is moving in the right direction.” Katz, June 9, 2006. WFP

“Last year’s budget increase was “a positive step in the right direction while trying to balance competing priorities with limited financial resources,” a spokesman for the mayor said.” Katz [via spokesman] Sept. 26, 2006. WFP

“There are a lot of steps going in the right direction,” Katz spokesman Salyn March 14, 2007.  WFP

“We’re going in the right direction. Before, we were going nowhere,” Katz, Mar. 14, 2007. Winnipeg Sun

“There’s so much more to do,” he said. “It just gratifying that others acknowledge we’re moving in the right direction.” Katz, Mar 21 2007 WFP

“I believed I could build consensus among council and get our city moving in the right direction. This budget shows we can accomplish this.” Katz, March 25, 2007, Winnipeg Sun column.

“Winnipeggers gave me a strong mandate to get Winnipeg moving in the right direction.” June 24, 2007, Sun column.

“There’s no secret we need change. We just want to make sure we change in the right direction.” Katz, Sept. 27, 2007 WFP

“I think we’re moving in the right direction,” Katz, Feb 18, 2010 WFP



Crime declines nationally, but not provincially – Winnipeg Free Press.

The severity of violent crime in Winnipeg is up by 15 per cent over 2008.

We’re urban Canada’s homicide capital, yet again.

With 57 homicides in 2009, Manitoba reported the highest homicide rate among the provinces for the third consecutive year. Manitoba has a homicide rate of 4.7 per every 100,000 residents. Only the Yukon and Northwest Territories ranked worse.”

On a brighter note, car thefts are down by 25 per cent.

Revitalizing Downtown Winnipeg: The Next Steps Forward (via The View from Seven)

Interesting info here. Worth reading for some outside the bubble perspective.

Revitalizing Downtown Winnipeg: The Next Steps Forward It's a question that has stumped Winnipeggers for more than a generation: how to reverse the decline of downtown Winnipeg and, in particular, Portage Avenue. At one time, downtown Winnipeg was the place to be. Portage Avenue was one of Canada's great downtown boulevards, lined with office buildings, restaurants, retail stores and movie theatres. It was the kind of place where a person could spend the better part of an entire day without getting b … Read More

via The View from Seven

Famous Winnipeg writer dies

Mary George/Family Photo

Mary George, an internationally-acclaimed bestselling writer who wrote under the name Elizabeth Thornton, died July 12 after a short battle with an auto-immune disease that attacked her liver.

She was 70.

Mary and her husband, were, just up to a few months ago, my parents next-door neighbours. I also used to look after them from time to time when they would come in to the restaurant I worked at while in university.

Mary’s memorial service was Friday.

She grew up in Scotland and became an educator, eventually starting her own nursery school. When she was about 30, she moved to Canada and taught here as well.

For 11 years, she was a Pastoral Assistant at Winnipeg’s First Presbyterian Church. After 11 years, she gave it up to tackle writing full-time.

Since then, she wrote 27 historical romance novels, which underscored her love and study of history.

I didn’t know her well enough to say anything other than anytime I saw her, it was an abosolute pleasure.

She would always ask how my studies were going and seemed to always be in a good mood. I can say my mother and father were completely shocked and saddened to hear she had died.

My thoughts today are with her husband and children and their children.

She maintained a website here under her pen-name, and wikipedia also has a brief entry on her literary achievements and background.

Uptown’s call to action

Uptown Mag’s Mike Warkentin on the Mayoralty race:

“In a perfect world, the media would keep track of the lies, and sometimes they do. Other times, members of the media are too busy doing too much with too little to do the kind of reporting that makes politicians squirm.

“So you do it. Get a pen and paper and write down every promise that you hear. Then, when you get a sense that you’ve been lied to yet again, go forth with your evidence and get in the face of an elected
representative. Make them accountable…”


Sorry for the blurry pic – I was just passing by Portage Place a few minutes ago and noticed something.

Those red and yellow blobs are actual security guards and downtown BIZ watch people in front of crack dealer’s alley.

Admittedly, they may just be there for ‘crowd’ control as there was (another smart idea) a concert in front of the mall.

They should be posted there 24-7.